Rubber mulch vs. wood mulch.
Wood mulch costs less to buy once. Rubber mulch holds its color far longer than wood mulch. It doesn't rot like wood, so you re-mulch far less often. Here is how the two compare, point by point.
Is rubber mulch better than wood mulch?
Over time, yes. Wood mulch costs less to buy once. It fades to gray in a single season, while a 12-year color guarantee covers every painted rubber mulch color. Rubber mulch doesn't rot like wood, so you re-mulch far less often.
Color
Wood mulch fades to gray in a single season. A 12-year color guarantee covers every painted rubber mulch color.
Upkeep
Wood mulch rots and needs replacing. Rubber mulch doesn't break down like wood, so you top it off rarely.
Cost
Wood mulch costs less to buy once. With rubber mulch you pay more up front and far less over the next decade.
Rubber mulch vs. wood mulch, point by point.
| Rubber mulch | Wood mulch | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost to buy | Costs more up front | Costs less to buy once |
| Color | 12-year color guarantee on every painted color | Fades to gray in a single season |
| Re-mulching | Topped off rarely | Needs replacing |
| Rot | Doesn't rot like wood | Rots |
| Mold and fungus | Gives mold and fungi nothing to feed on | Hosts fungi when damp, such as artillery fungus |
| Insects | Gives termites and carpenter ants nothing to eat | Draws insects |
| Rain | Stays in place better than wood in ordinary rain | Washes out more easily |
| Soil | Adds no organic matter | Breaks down and adds organic matter |
| Splinters in a play area | Doesn't splinter like wood chips | Can splinter |
| Packing down in a play area | Does not compress in the same manner as other loose fill (U.S. CPSC) | Compresses by at least a quarter over time (U.S. CPSC) |
The 12-year color guarantee is Perfect Rubber Mulch's written warranty on painted colors. Compression: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Public Playground Safety Handbook (Publication 325). Artillery fungus in wood mulch: Penn State Extension.
Rubber mulch vs. wood mulch, answered.
Is rubber mulch better than wood mulch for landscaping?
For color that lasts and less re-mulching, yes. Wood mulch fades to gray in a single season. A 12-year color guarantee covers every painted rubber mulch color.
Wood mulch rots and needs replacing. Rubber mulch doesn't break down like wood, so you top it off rarely. In an ornamental bed, both hold moisture and block weeds. See rubber mulch for landscaping →
Is rubber mulch better than wood for a playground?
For cushioning that holds up year after year, yes. Our rubber mulch is IPEMA-certified and ASTM F1292 fall-height tested to cushion falls.
The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission says loose fill such as wood chips compresses by at least a quarter over time. It says rubber loose fill does not compress in the same manner. See how playground surfaces compare →
Does rubber mulch cost more than wood mulch?
Yes, up front. Wood mulch costs less to buy once, but it rots and needs replacing. With rubber mulch you pay more up front and far less over the next decade.
Does rubber mulch last longer than wood mulch?
Yes, years longer. Rubber mulch doesn't break down like wood or compact, so a bed or play area goes many years before it needs more than a minor top-off. A 12-year guarantee covers the color.
Does rubber mulch grow mold or fungus like wood mulch?
Rubber gives mold and fungi nothing to feed on. Damp wood and bark mulch host fungi, including artillery fungus. Rubber doesn't decompose like wood or absorb water. Penn State Extension on artillery fungus in mulch →
Is wood mulch better for plants and soil?
Wood mulch does one thing rubber mulch doesn't: it breaks down and adds organic matter to your soil. In an ornamental bed, both hold moisture and block weeds.
Pick a color and get free curbside delivery.
See your exact delivered price online, or request a quote for a larger project.
